Thursday, September 26, 2013

A Negative Review: Elfen Lied Sucks

I hate anime so fucking much

Ok guys, let's face it... Elfen Lied sucks. It is universally regarded as one of the best anime, however, often for some combination of the following... "unbeatable plot," "flawless delivery," "moral degradation of society manifested via sensational gore," or– well, it only gets increasingly pretentious. So here are some things to consider:


1. How often can characters conveniently end up along the same beachside in a given town, across the span of a week? And then keep running into each other with absurd consistency? Without these handy-dandy contrivances, the plot would not move forward.

2. Every single character is a stereotype. The protagonist, Lucy, is the worst offender – she may as well  be the textbook definition of "genetically-modified/robot girl." But it doesn't stop there. Apparently every other cute girl in the show has incredible super powers, but always in direct proportion to their inherently correspondingly sad personal history. The supporting cast follows the same trend... there is the well-meaning yet regretful father figure... the handsome yet naive nice guy which every single female character without fail immediately wants to fuck... the equally naive girl whose efforts to fuck the handsome yet naive nice guy are consistently thwarted by her idiocy, and her desire to keep trying not waning in the presence of said guy's greater idiocy... the gung-ho ex-special forces S.A.S. GIGN sub-terrain-ninja-commando-warlock whose expertise with weapons is exceeded only by his stupidity... and last but not least, the cute little girl who's actually a malevolent demon hellbent on murdering everyone she sees.

3. The characters with superpowers are able to use their powers to a degree of effectiveness inversely proportional to the relevance their victim has to the plot. No other explanation is given as to why the girls can't always fire on all cylinders. Through lazy writing and plot contrivances, the girls can massacre an army's worth of well-armed and trained men yet take an entire episode to deliver a blow in excess of a swift breeze to a major character.

4. The nudity is absurd. Literally within the first 10 seconds of the intro you've already seen the main character butt-naked, and within 10 minutes of the first episode, you get more of the same. Actually, this is true of nearly every episode (regarding more than just the protagonist, anyway...). Some poor fools would argue that this nudity is a manifestation of the child-like innocence or purity of the given characters whenever it is shown – however, this is so overdone by the 100th time it happens that it loses all meaning. For that matter, the central theme of innocence and discrimination is entirely conveyed through the first episode; it is pointless to watch beyond that if you're only doing it for the philosophy the fanboys (and girls!) have convinced you lies beneath the surface. And while we're at it, let's just ask ourselves if it's really such a big deal that innocence and discrimination are even being discussed – what, this is the first time you've heard of this shtick? Perhaps in anime, perhaps anywhere; in either case, go watch Grave of the Fireflies which is everything Elfen Lied wishes it was and more, yet ironically (and thankfully), in much shorter a runtime.

So basically, Elfen Lied is just a generic superpowered-kawaii-girl type thing for schoolgirl fetishists.

7 comments:

  1. you can't except anything to be perfect and normal viewers don't resarch stuff that deep like you

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eh, "perfect." The word implies a whole set of nauseating attributions like "perfect movie," "flawless acting," or "unbeatable plot..."

      But who wants perfect? Interesting and more or less articulate is what I'm looking for. Elfen Lied, to me, is not that. On the contrary, I think it's full of dumb stuff such as what I tried to outline in this post... but it's all opinion.

      If you're able to enjoy it, power to you.

      Delete
    2. Well, we SHOULD be expecting grown men not to make entire series so they can jerk off to the suffering of little girls.

      Delete
  2. I share your viewpoint.

    The excessive tendency for the MC to act stupid beyond stupidest of stupid was especially exasperating for me while watching the anime.

    I'm still puzzled as to how people like this shit and why it got its popularity...But before my POV possibly initiates a bickering amongst us, I'll say, to each his own.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. People of all ages watch anime. However, the majority is probably in the 14-18 age group, and it's also that age group that happens to be the most vocal.

      When you put a bunch of those guys in the same room and give them something seemingly "edgy" and "controversial" like Elfen Lied, the popularity you refer to is what ensues.

      Meanwhile, incredible stuff like Cowboy Bebop is unheard of.

      Delete
  3. People of today watch this crap i preffer to watch my childhood animes just like Hokuto No Ken,Slam Dunk,Roruni Kenshin,Kishin Doji Zenki,DBZ,Ranma 1/2 those are good animes

    ReplyDelete
  4. Also keep in mind that the whole concept of the Diclonii, the horned mutant girls who have these superpowers, is contrived and illogical. If they are able to infect the genetics of all humans by just touching them with their "hands" or powers, and they have existed in Earth for a significantly longer time (I think for thousands of years or so), AND that they are supposed to be this big threat to humanity, HOW exactly did they not "replace" humanity long ago. Plot Hole. And how can they possibly be born with an instinctual desire to both kill and infect humans. That's completely counteractive to the goal of a species to survive. Even animals, with an instinctive desire to be violent, have reasonable motivations for violence for the most part; such as territory, feeling threatened, or to eat. It is only because animals focus on survival. Having a species designed with the instinctive intention to hurt humans as well as repopulate via a sort of genetic cuckoo makes no sense. They would have been destroyed long ago.

    ReplyDelete